SALILDA MUSIC HAS NO LANGUAGE ( PART 2) ( Vol 35 Down Memory Lane)
![]() |
| Salil Chowdhrey |
As Bimal Roy booked Kishore Kumar to play the film’s jobless hero opposite heroine Sheila Ramani in the movie Naukri, our singing-star performer assumed that he himself would be rendering the numbers going on the leading man. But Salil Chowdhury invited Hemant Kumar to playback his songs in Naukri, without informing Kishore, who was aghast when he heard about it. Salil gave this tune to Shailendra who immediately wrote the lyrics a genius.
Kishore
rushed to Salil’s music room (at Mohan Studios, Andheri), humbly demanding to
know why he was being eliminated, as a singer, from his own starrer.
‘But
I’ve never heard you before!’ came back Salil Chowdhury as
one new to Bombay. ‘Kishore modestly replied: ‘Then, at least, do please
hear me now, Salilda. I have always rendered my songs myself in Bombay cinema.’
The
moment Kishore began singing, Salil cut him short, observing: ‘You don’t
know the ABC of music “. Hemant Kumar will sing, on you, Chhota sa ghar
hogaa.’ Distraught, Kishore rushed to the great Bimal Roy to represent his
case in the highest court of appeal. Only to hear him say: ‘Music is Salil
Chowdhury’s department. My music director decides who sings what.’
That
effectively shunted back Kishore to Salil – a Kishore, and he then carried with
him as proof of his vocal potential. his own 78-rpm records, in a desperate
attempt to prove his vocal worth to the Salil Chowdhury. For all that Kishore
effort, Salil Chowdhury, the phenomenon from West Bengal, remained unconvinced.
Whereupon others put in a word, underlining that the lad’s career, as a
singing-star, had yet to take off and any attempt to employ a playback, for
him, could prove to be morale-shattering. Somehow Salil relented, even while
insisting: ‘But this Kishore lad is no singer, I tell you!’.
There
were 2 versions of the song sad one by Hemant Kumar and the happy one by
Kishore in the same film. Finally, Salil Chowdhury had Kishore leading the
wistful way in 2 more songs in the same Naukri after this one!
After having nearly traumatized the hugely gifted Kishore, the same Salil Chowdhury stood wonderstruck, some 17 years later, as Kishore returned for Gulzar’s Mere Apne to deliver for him (as ‘voiced over’ on Vinod Khanna) Koee hotaa jis ko apnaa hum apnaa keh letey yaaron full of pathos. After this recording Salil acknowledged later
‘I salute Dada Burman for spotting the
spark in the boy so early, when all of us woefully misjudged Kishore’s talent.’
Koee hotaa jis ko apnaa hum apnaa k keh letey yaaron. Mere Apne (1971)
Salil was full of musical ideas for film maker Dulal Guha in association with his pet poet Shailendra, for the Mala Sinha–Talat Mahmood starrer, Ek Gaaon Ki Kahani. This is what happens when composer and singer are on the same creative wavelength as manifest here. Salil has Talat (as the film’s hero) engrossingly enacting Raat ne kyaa kyaa khwab dikhaye. Talat’s silky voice will melt your heart with the pathos one of the finest Talat Salil numbers.
In Kerala Salil Chowdhury has become a household name and is highly revered. Along with Malayalee lyricist Vayalar and the poet ONV Kurup Salil composed music for over 25 Malayalam Films. This is one of Yesudas’s favorite of Salil which he used to sing in his stage shows at his prime.
Ormakale
Kaivale Charthi Pratheeksha (Malayalam) 1968
All Hrishikesh Mukherjee did
venture, some 25 years later (in 1970), to get Lata to compose for Rajesh
Khanna– Amitabh Bachchan’s Anand. But Lata politely declined. Imagine, if she
had agreed, who would have brought form and colour to Salil Chowdhury’s
proudest-ever composition, Na jiyaa laage na –in Raag Gaara on Sumita
Sanyal? Lata sang both Hindi and Bengali versions of the song.
Na
Jiya Laage Naa Anand (1971)
The voice of Mukesh, the words of Yogesh and
the lilting melody by Chowdhury, this song is the one that really takes
listeners and viewers through the sadness of the titular character, Anand
(Rajesh Khanna), who is otherwise determinedly cheerful in the face of his
terminal illness. Original Bengali version sung by Hemant Kumar Amay Proshno Kore for which the lyrics is by Sali itself
Kahin Door Jab Din Dhal Jaaye (Anand, 1971)
“This is what I have been telling you,
music is a universal language. That Rajnigandha (1974) song Kai
Baar Unhin Dekha Hai Ye Jo Mann Ki Seema Rekha Hai... I used in Malayalam
film in Yesudas’ voice. I used in Bangla also and they were hits. “
Kai Baar Unhin Dekha Hai ... Rajnigandha (1974)
B. R. Chopra condescended to bring back Lata, to record the Salil Chowdhury-tuned Na jaane kyun hotaa hai yeh zindagee ke saath, voiced over on Vidya Sinha (vis-à-vis Amol Palekar). Such as this gorgeous melody sung by Lata Mangeshkar shot in Bombay’s bustling bylanes, old bungalows, BEST buses and iconic restaurants forming the perfect backdrop for this story.
Na
Jaane Kyon Chhoti Si Baat) (1976)
To the music connoisseur he was better known as the non-conformist music composer whose unceasing search for perfection towered above everything else in his life. His meticulous attention to details, a scrupulous ear for musical content and insatiable desire for improvisation - it all remained with him till his last days. He was in fact a composer's composer, because unlike his market-driven counterpart, he never really set prose to music. To him the melody was sacrosanct and had to precede the words. The situation could then be adapted.Salil's music was a unique blend of the east and the west. Salil said about his unconventional song
“I remember while recording a
song for Annadata, it
took Kishore two days to get the composition. The song was Guzar Jaye Din Din.
Guzar
Jaye Din Din. Annadata (1972)
Balu
Mahendra first movie as director was Kokila in Kannada. It had Salil as
music director. Balu Mahendra said about his first movie which is also actor
Mohan’s first movie. S Janaki sang this tune which had blend of melody, humming
and western background a true blend of east and west. Lata sang the Bengali
version of the same song Aaj noy goon goon. While Salil always preferred
Lata both for Hindi and Bengali for most songs when it comes to south his
choice was mostly S Janaki.
Balu Mahendra said this in
an event
“Salilda, an emotional man, was the
first music director I met who
knew what it took to compose music for cinema”
Sanje Tangaali Kokila Kannada 1977
Sagarame Santhamake Nee Madanolsavam Malayalam (1978)
Balu Mahendra’s second movie
was Azhiyatha Kolangal
his first in in Tamil and what a music from Salil. This song Poo Vannam
sung by Jayachandran and versatile P Suseela is proof of his versatility.
Ilayaraja worked as guitarist in Salil orchestra in the
beginning of his career not known to
many in the south. Later films of Balu Mahendra had music by Ilayaraja.
Ilayaraja said this about
Salil.
“Salil was an
inspiration. I have imbibed a lot from him.”
Balu Mahendra said this in the same event
“In the last 25
years, there's not been a single session where Ilaiyaraja and I have not spoken
of this genius Salil."
Like Salil S Janaki became favorite singer
for Ilayaraja in future for Tamil hits .
POO VANNAM
AZHITHA KOLANGAL TAMIL (1979)
His
occasional flirtations with Mozart or Bach, his experiments with the relative
minor and major scales, with harmonized choral singing, modern chord
progression was mind blowing blend of East and West.
Salil Chowdhury also
composed jingles for Lipton Tea, Hamam Soap etc .
In
the end Salil moved away from Bombay and set up his own recording studio.
“”
I realise Bombay is no more for me... this kind of music... I am not
suitable for. I find myself to be a misfit in Bombay’s filmy music scene. So I
made this sound recording studio and I
wanted to experiment with the electronic medium in music. So many synthesisers
and other modern musical equipment...the scope of a composer has gone up
hundreds folds... You will find, in the West, all composers, have their own
studios. I go to Bombay just to do music for TV serials “
About
his own career this is what Salil said towards the end.
“
An artist cannot be satisfied. I feel I could have done much better. I have not
given even 30 % of my imagination... so that remains. But I have a sense of
fulfilment. I have got tremendous love from all over the country and that
satisfies me. And my feeling reflects in the song, Zindagi Kaisi Hai Paheli... sung
by Manna Dey for Anand.
Zindagi
Kaise Ke Paheli Anand
Salil
Chowdhrey symbolizes modernity. You had to be at a Salil Chowdhury recording,
based entirely on the chords’ system, to divine what orchestral integration
really meant. Everything would be sounding great, just great, when the man
would chip in with: ‘Cut, cut!’ A cut above the rest was Salil Chowdhury, a
composer.
To
the music connoisseur he was better known as the non-conformist music composer
whose unceasing search for perfection towered above everything else in his
life. His meticulous attention to details, a scrupulous ear for musical content
and insatiable desire for improvisation - it all remained with him till his
last days. He was in fact a composer's composer, because unlike his
market-driven counterpart, he never really set prose to music. To him the
melody was sacrosanct and had to precede the words. The situation could then be
adapted.
My humble tribute to Salil on his 28th Death Anniversary September 5th 2023.
References
Bharatan,
Raju. A Journey Down Melody Lane
Suhana safar' with Salilda Dinesh
Krishnajois the Hindu Article 23Nov 2004
Interview with S Janaki
Salil Interview with MK Jha

What an extensive piece on Salil Da..!
ReplyDeleteThank you Sir!
DeleteSimply amazing write-up again! I wonder from which resources you manage to pick such interesting tit-bits of behind-the-scenes of Salilda’s compositions. Lot of interesting nuggets like Kishore Kumar’s desperation to sing for ‘Naukri’ (I can’t imagine Hemantda’s voice for ‘Chota sa ghar hoga’ - Probably the composition would have been different), Lata being offered to compose music for ‘Anand’ (I used to wonder why all the great singers barring a few never tried to compose) and Salilda considered melody as sacrosanct and made the lyrics fit the metre. This was evident in some of his composition where the lyrics seemed to have compressed and fit in or either drawl at the end to fill the metre. But invariably that unique Salilda style used to come to the fore with its unmistakable stamp. Interesting to note that ‘Kai baar yunhi’ had a Malayalam version too. May be you can add that on in your blog. Enjoyed this! Thanks 👍😊
DeleteThanks Nathan for your analysis of Salil music.There was only one journalist in the golden era of music for Filmfare who was music critic and who reviewed all the composers music and inside info about how music was created.He used to be with all the music directors.Raju Bharathan who is from south. .Most of the info like Kishore episode is from his book which is in the reference.I also could get access to interviews with Salil. It took me almost a month to write the 2 parts.Appreciate your kind words.Enjoyed this deep dive into this great music director Thanks. Sivaram
Delete